Contraventions / Breaching Orders
A party is taken to have contravened a parenting order (whether it is an interim or final parenting order) if the party is bound by the order and:
- The party has intentionally failed to comply with the order; or
- The party has made no reasonable attempt to comply with the order.
When determining whether a parenting order has been contravened the Court can make the following determinations:
- The contravention is alleged to have occurred but is not established;
- The contravention has occurred but there is a reasonable excuse for the contravention; or
- The contravention has occurred and there is no reasonable excuse for the contravention.
The Contravention is Alleged but not Established:
If the party filing the Application cannot establish that the other party contravened the parenting order the Court can make an order for that party to pay some or all of the other party’s costs for responding to the Application.
The Contravention has Occurred but There is a Reasonable Excuse for the Contravention:
If the party is found to have contravened the parenting order the next step is for the Court to determine whether that party had a reasonable excuse for contravening the order. To determine this the Court must be satisfied of the following:
The party contravened the order because he or she did not, at the time of the contravention, understand the obligations imposed on her/him by the order; or
The party believed on all reasonable grounds that the actions which led to the contravention were necessary to protect the health and/or safety of the child or the party.
If the Court finds that a party had a reasonable excuse for contravening the orders the Court must then consider making a further parenting order to compensate the party who did not spend time with the child as a result of the contravention. However, the Court is not required to make this order, only to consider it.
The Contravention has Occurred but there is no Reasonable Excuse for the Contravention:
If the Court has found that a party contravened a parenting order without reasonable excuse, on the balance of probabilities, the Court can make an Order for the contravening party to complete community service, enter into a bond for a period of time and/or in accordance with specific provisions, for example to attend counselling or a parenting program or a sentence of imprisonment until the order is complied with or for a specific period of time.
Varying Parenting Orders:
Whether the contravention has or has not been established the Court has the power to vary any parenting Orders made. The Court also has the power to make an Order for the contravening party to complete a post separation parenting program.
If you require further assistance with your contravention application please contact one of our Melbourne Family Law Solicitors.
WHERE TO NEXT?
Taking the next step and contacting a family lawyer can be scary. Our lawyers will make you feel comfortable so you can talk about your situation. But first, ask yourself, Do I really need a lawyer?